Zen and Understanding Middle East News and Issues
|Zionism Israel||documents||photos||help us|
Zionism & Israel Center Zionism and Israel Pages MidEastWeb Middle East News Views & Facts
"The truth is out there "
Fallacies and Arguments
Reference: Appeal to Authority
Arguments based on authority are, in a way, the opposite of the "Ad Hominem type error. An argument cannot be discounted solely because the person who advances it is distasteful or has a bad character, nor can it be accepted solely because the person is an "authority." LaBossiere notes that arguments based on the opinions of "authorities" are not cogent if the persons are not experts in the field. The opinions of an American movie star or a millionaire about the Middle East are not more valid than those of their taxi driver. Unfortunately, the millionaire or the movie star have far greater resources and can use them to make their opinions known and ensure that they are respected.
However, appeal to authority regarding questions of empirical fact is always risky, no matter what the status of the person in question. Experts and authorities can only give definitive statements about matters which it is in their competence to define. The king can define the law of the realm. If he says poaching is against the law, then it is true by definition. The religious authorities can define the laws of religion. If they say poaching is immoral, then it is immoral. But if the king or the moral authorities say 'there is no poaching in the land,' it may be true or not, and it doesn't depend on their authority. If brother John saw Bill Smith shoot a deer, then it doesn't matter a bit if King Henry proclaimed that there is no poaching.
The greatest authorities in the world believed, prior to the 19th century, that heavier than air flight was impossible, that men would never walk on the moon, that "negroid" "races" were "inferior" to "caucasoid" "races, and many other things we no longer hold to be true.
Regarding the Middle East, you can find an authority to back any opinion or point of view and to advance just about any factual assertion. Choose the right authority and you can put the population of "Palestine" (no such political entity at the time) in 1900 at anywhere from 200,000 to about 500,000 souls (see here ) , and you can spin all manner of arguments based on that. You can find authorities who insist that radical Islamism will evolve to moderate democracy, and authorities who insist that the opposite is true. They all have cogent arguments and data to back their assertions.
John Esposito and Bernard Lewis are both authorities on the Middle East, but they have opposing views on many questions. The only thing we can say is that the fact that Bernard Lewis or John Esposito are recognized authorities on the Middle East makes it far more likely that there is some truth in their opinions than in those of John Doe, who is from Smallville USA, and can't find the Middle East on a map. They may both agree on the facts, but their interpretation of those facts will be different.
The fact that we cannot rely only on authorities for an understanding of the Middle East presents a real problem. As we noted, humans rely on others for most of our information. If we are sick, we go to a doctor to get a diagnosis and we rely on his or her opinion. If we want to know the capital of Afghanistan we consult a book, and if we want to know how a computer or an automobile works we consult other books written by authorities, or we consult experts. But regarding political questions, and especially in the Middle East, it is virtually impossible to find an unbiased political expert.
Read/Download the entire book (PDF)
This site provides resources about Zionism and Israeli history, including links to source documents. We are not responsible for the information content of these sites. These links are NOT intended to be an exhaustive reference about Zionism, but the list will keep growing...
Please tell us about your favorite links and we will review them for inclusion.
Please be careful to credit the Zionism pages and link to us. Please do
copy these links to your Web site, giving credit to Zionism Israel Center
Sister sites : Zionism Pages Brave Zionism
Zionism and Israel information center and Zionism and Israel On the Web
Sister sites : Zionism Pages Brave Zionism Zionism and Israel information center and Zionism and Israel On the WebBrave Zionism
MidEastWeb History of Israel Palestine and the Middle East Conflict conflict
MidEastWeb Middle East News, Views, Maps and History
Zionism Definition and Brief History A balanced article that covers the definitions and history of Zionism as well as opposition to Zionism and criticisms by Arabs, Jewish antiZionists.
Labor Zionism History and Critique Contribution of Labor Zionism to the creation of the Jewish state, and problems of Labor Zionism in a changing reality.
Concise Guide to IsraeliZionist CyberSpace
Israel-Palestina (Dutch) Middle East Conflict, Israel, Palestine,Zionism... Israël-Palestina Informatie gids Israël, Palestijnen en Midden-Oosten conflict... Israeli-Palestinian conflict from a European perspective Dutch and English.
English Israel-Palestine.info Guide to the Middle East Conflict (Peace, Zionism, antiSemitism ...)
Active Zionism A Zionist advocacy site with many useful links
PEACE Watch Middle East Dialog and Peace Process
Pnews Progressive Views on Zionism Israel Jews & AntiSemitism
ZioNation - Zionism-Israel Web Log Zionism & Israel News Israel: like this, as if History of Zionism Zionism FAQ Zionism Israel Center Maps of Israel Jew Zionism and its ImpactIsrael Christian Zionism Site Map