EU, US, stop short of vetoing Palestinian state

Contrary to what the headline below, and similar headlines, would have you believe, neither the EU nor the United States have indicated they would veto a bid for recognition of a unilaterally declared Palestinian state in the UN Security Council. Read what they said, not what we would want them to say.  The EU stated:

 

Swedish Foreign Minister Carl Bildt, whose country holds the EU presidency, explained that the EU does not believe conditions are ripe yet for such a move. The EU is not on the Security Council, but EU members France and Britain are permanent council members that wield veto power

Conditions are not ripe yet, but in two years they might be ripe. "Does not believe" does not mean, "we will veto."

 

And the United States' declaration is similarly indecisive:

 

"It is our strong belief and conviction that the best means to achieve the common goal of a contiguous and viable Palestine is through negotiations between the parties," the U.S. State Department said in a statement.

A unilateral declaration of statehood may not be the best means to achieve anything in the view of the United States, but that doesn't translated into a veto. It does not mean the United States or the EU would stop underwriting the Palestinian Authority if they declare a state. Moreover, even without Security Council recognition, a Palestinian state would be automatically recognized by all Muslim countries, and by several South American countries such as Venezuela and perhaps Brazil. China might also recognize such a state.

 

Ami Isseroff

 

Last update - 11:34 17/11/2009       
EU rejects Palestinian bid for unilateral declaration of state
By Haaretz Service and News Agencies

 

The European Union has rejected the Palestinian Authority's request to back its plan for gaining recognition as an independent state at the United Nations Security Council without Israeli consent.

 

Swedish Foreign Minister Carl Bildt, whose country holds the EU presidency, explained that the EU does not believe conditions are ripe yet for such a move. The EU is not on the Security Council, but EU members France and Britain are permanent council members that wield veto power.

 

The EU's foreign ministers on Tuesday were discussing ways to coordinate with the United States to get Palestinians and Israelis back to the negotiating table.
 
"The Palestinian plan is clearly an act borne by a difficult situation where they don't see any road ahead," said Bildt.

 

The Palestinian Authority is coming under increasing pressure ­ from Israel and the international community ­to back down from its threat to unilaterally declare a state without first concluding a peace agreement with Israel.

 

On Monday evening, the United States on Monday reaffirmed its support for the resolution of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict through negotiations, in its first official response to the Palestinian plan.

 

"It is our strong belief and conviction that the best means to achieve the common goal of a contiguous and viable Palestine is through negotiations between the parties," the U.S. State Department said in a statement.

 

U.S. senators visiting Israel said earlier in the day that on Monday that Washington would veto a Palestinian declaration of statehood in the United Nations Security Council.

 

The idea of seeking UN intervention has been gaining steam in the Arab world as the impasse in peacemaking drags on. The Palestinians seek a state in the West Bank, Gaza Strip and east Jerusalem, territories Israel captured in 1967.

 

The senators said the threat by Palestinian officials to take the issue to a UN resolution was a waste of time and would go nowhere. They urged Arab states to stop it.

 

"It would be D.O.A. - dead on arrival," Democratic Party Senator Ted Kaufman (DE) told a news conference in Jerusalem. "It's a waste of time."

 

Senator Joseph Lieberman (CT), an independent, said "an essentially unilateral" declaration of statehood was the one thing that would not move the stalled peace process forward."